where answers why
January 18, 2012
Your studies this week have centered on New Testament background. Check out the following blog by Dr. Brassfield. He masterfully uses NT background information to illuminate the Day of Pentecost.
So to get to the real meaning of Pentecost, lets first look at the location of the outpouring. I believe that the where will answer the why and help us understand that first outpouring at a much deeper level.
First it is a general assumption among most Pentecostal and evangelical groups for that matter, to believe that the Holy Spirit fell in the Upper Room. This is probably because of the biblical references to the upper room in other New Testament passages such as; Luke 22:12 and Mark 14:15 which speak of a common event, the upper room of the “Lord’s Supper”, and Acts 1:13 which speaks of an upper room where the disciples of Jesus were staying during the Feast of Pentecost. It is logical, though not expressly indicated in Scripture, that this accommodation would have been one and the same place. And there has been much speculation as to the relationship that Jesus and His disciples might have had with the particular owner of this upper room. Maybe it was a familiar place that they often used when visiting Jerusalem. Perhaps they rented it? Or, it might have been simply loaned to them by a family member or friend. Jewish residents of Jerusalem would often offer hospitality to pilgrims who had come to Jerusalem for the three chief Feast of Israel. Whatever the case, we have traditionally assumed that it is there, in the upper room, that the Holy Spirit was poured out on that day. But does the Scripture actually say that? No!
Luke in Acts chapter one tells us that they return to Jerusalem, after Jesus ascension to heaven from the Mount of Olives, to the Upper room, “where they were staying” (Acts 1:13) While there, they conducted the business of replacing Judas position of leadership with another of their number who had been faithful and had been with them since Jesus baptism in water by John and we are told that they continued in one mind and one accord.
But Luke uses a Hebraic-styled narrative break[1] to introduce chapter two and the events of chapter two. This in other words changed the flow of the story and disconnected everything going on in chapter one from that of chapter two.
Acts 2:1 When the Day of Pentecost had fully come, they were all with one accord in one place.”This change let’s the reader know that where the disciples were and what they were doing in chapter one is not necessarily where they are and what they are doing as chapter two opens.
Now let’s remember that they are devout Jews. And this fact has to be accounted for in the story of Pentecost. We must assume that they continued in their Jewish traditions after Jesus Ascension. They did not understand, as of yet, the distinction that would develop between Judaism and Christianity. They, during feast times and regularly scheduled prayer times would have almost certainly followed their Jewish traditions. Luke tells us as he closes his gospel in chapter Luke 24: 52 and53 “And they worshiped Him, and returned to Jerusalem with great joy, and were continually in the Temple praising and blessing God. Amen.” No doubt when it was time to pray they would have went to the Temple for their normal prayer times. We even see that evidenced later in Acts chapter 3 verse one when Peter and John encounter the lame man at the gate called Beautiful, begging. He is of course healed in the encounter but Luke tells us they are there presumably to pray because its prayer time, “…the hour of prayer, the ninth hour”. Acts 3:1
This understanding gives us a bit more insight into the Acts chapter two story. Being devout Jews and clearly seeing that they demonstrated no apparent reason to reject the Temple or their associated Jewish customs, where are they likely to have been when the “Day of Pentecost had fully come?”
Pentecost is the only one of Israel’s chief feast that was celebrated on a single day as opposed to a week or at least over several days. The doors of the Temple opened just after midnight to allow the visiting crowds to have their sacrifices inspected by the priest. The services began with the morning sacrifices being offered and then prayer time followed around the third hour of the day, between 9 to 10 am. Large numbers of Pilgrims, perhaps ten of thousands, [2]would have been there having traveled from all over the World. Luke gives us a list of the different nationalities present. Acts 2: 5-13.
It is unthinkable that the disciples would miss the morning ceremonies associated with the Feast of Pentecost. Indeed it would have been disobedient to the command of the Lord from the Torah. Exodus 34:23-24. So for them to have been in a neighborhood near but not present at the Temple is not realistic.
Yes the scripture does say that the Spirit “filled the house where they were sitting” Acts 2:2. But the house referred to was most likely the Temple.
The Center for Holy Land Studies of the Assemblies of God suggest, that in Hebrew, the moscommon term used to refer to the Temple is “house”. The Temple Mount is referred to as “the mountain of the house”; cf. m. Bikkurim 3:4). At this point within the Greek narrative of Acts, Luke often preserves Hebraic-styled syntax and idiom. His narrative mention of the “house” in which the disciples sat quite likely reflects this Hebrew idiom referring to the Temple, which is where one would expect to find Jesus’ disciples on the festival of Pentecost as well as the crowds they encounter.[3]
So to set this possibility in motion lets imagine the scene. Tens of thousands of devoted Jews from all over the World have gathered for this one-day grand celebration that was both a celebration of the first fruits of the Barley harvest and the commemoration of the giving of the law to Moses at Mt Sinai. The sacrifices have been offered, sections of the Torah recited and songs sung. The people have gathered in ethnic groups to read the Torah and pray when suddenly the place is shaken by the sound of a rushing mighty wind. All the believers in Christ who were present, mostly from the regions of Galilee, begin to speak loudly giving glory to God and testifying of his wonderful works; speaking in the diverse native languages of the pilgrims who were present at the Feast. The people are amazed!
Peter the Apostle stands to speak and explain what they are witnessing. Luke records his message for us in Acts 2: 14-39. He explains that they are not drunk as some had supposed since it is the third hour of the day, (prayer time by the way), but rather he attributes the outpouring as the fulfillment of the prophet Joel. He then preaches the gospel of Jesus to them as a suffering Messiah and the savior who had been crucified and resurrected from the dead. At the end of his message some 3,000 people respond to the gospel and are baptized. The only place in Jerusalem that could have accommodated that many hearing and being baptized was the Temple with its large outer court and ritual baths that were located at the southern entrance at the pilgrim’s gate to the Temple Mount. [4]
When we settle in our mind that the most likely place for the outpouring was the Jewish Temple and that God had purposely orchestrated the place and the time with such careful planning, I believe it helps us understand the why. And the why was so much greater than just the experience of power received by 120 gathered in an obscure upper room, it was to ignite a movement around the World in a single moment, as people were undoubtedly converted from all over the world at that one great event. It is as if God planned this moment to assist the fledgling disciples who had just received the Great Commission to take the good news all over the world to every creature. Pentecost was God’s sovereign way to override racial prejudice, ethnic barriers, gender issues and the natural resentment that the disciples must have felt toward the people of Jerusalem who had just participated in Jesus crucifixion. When many of them came to faith as a result of the work of the Holy Spirit all questions were answered; forgiveness was for everyone-even those who had participated in his death, and that every person from any country who called on the name of the Lord could be saved. The where answers the why.
I completely agree. For some reason I have believed that for quite some time. Who knows, I may have heard Dr. Brasfield speak of this in one of his many trips to Word of Life Church in Tupelo, Ms. The timing of the outpouring was exactly perfect as well as the timing in history. The expansion of the road system under the Roman empire and the common language under the prior Greek domination under Alexander gave the perfect setting for the gospel to explode out into the know world. For the outpouring to happen in the temple, at pentacost is just another perefect setting for God's great plan.
Wow, I have never heard this story of Acts from this perspective. It is definitely very neat how God had gathered people from all ethnic groups to experience this outpouring of His Holy Spirit. It is very true that this whole thing was in God's hands and He knew what He was doing and where He was going to do it. Thanks for this blog! Really opened my eyes.
This is why I enjoy this class. Thank You Dr. Brassfield for breaking this down and making us look at the scripture from a different view. There is not much to say but Wow!
Everyone has great input on this blog.I agree with everyone an this shows how amazing God is getting people togather an sharing the gospel.This goes to show how God worked through the people then and the same he works through us.
Awesome read.
I have always felt that because there were 3000 saved there needed to be more in attendance. That would indicate a large outdoor site, such as the temple grounds. There would not have been a room Niall of Jerusalem thatcouldhousethat many people. As was said we sometimes read without thought and thus just make assumptions. Really good article
good article
I have to agree with everyone else. This is another example of how dimensional the Word of God is and how important it is to dive deep and get how even the where answers the why.
I love that the simple translating of a paragraph break lead to the ultimate convincing of how I see the day of Pentecost in the new testament. It is amazingly enlightening. I always wondered how we made that transition from the upper room to the temple courts where thousands of people rested, in only a few sentences. I also wondered why there were so many different nationalities at that time. I used to just think Jerusalem must have been a year round tourist attraction. But the WHERE this happened makes all the sense WHY and WHEN this happened as well. Thank you Dr. Brassfield, it was really really good!
One of the things I love about my DLI experience is that we are encouraged to think! It's so easy to accept a ages old interpretation of the Bible without question! As we are exposed to blogs like this from scholars it ignites a hunger in me to be a scholar! God did not make us robots that only regurgitate only what He programs into us! He made us with free will & the ability to think! DLI is an answer to many prayers in my life on how God will use me & prepare me for ministry! I'm so thankful for God putting me here!
This helps me understand more clearly this story. Again this is why we sho"ld know the who, what, where, when, and whys! To just read it at face value does not give you the "BIG" picture. Thanks for sharing this, I really enjoyed it.
Again, this goes a long way to show us that we need to read scricpture in context, using the proper grammar tools to interpret what is being said. This is first time that I have heard this presented but it does make a lot of sense. The apostles and the others would have to have been accesible by the general public. All that Dr. Brassfield presents makes sense. We so carelessly interpret what we read and also never disect what we have heard. I have always been told and taught that what the pastor preaches you do not question just do and believe! Thank you for this eye opener!
Thank you for the blog. To know God is so amazing and powerful to orchestrate in this manner. To bring all of his people together in one place, purposed to spread the gospel of the kingdom to the entire world with one meeting, one place. I am thankful for all of the sharing on this subject.
WOW Again floored at how much difference it makes know the culture and the history of a certain time. It can completely change how we understand things. Thank you Dr. Brassfield
Excellent just read this passage a few weeks ago, and thought about how big the upper room was, and how many places in that day could hold over 3000 people,We would call that a Meg Church today. Looking forward to the next blog. God Bless You All
I really enjoyed this. Again it brings into Play that we need to know the cultural background. This was very educational.
I love this kind of detailed biblical info that is mixed with pertinent historical and cultural teachings. I think it is extremely important to study our long-held assumptions about stories in the Bible, and to offer sound alternatives to them when the evidence suggests them. These kind of details are invaluable, and serve to strengthen the message and remind us that these are events that really occurred in history and not just in the context of the written word.
That was an eye opening explanation and something I have never heard before. God is in the details and when he does something awesome, he wants as many people to witness and experience what He pours out. Thank you, Dr. Brassfield, for your study and for sharing with us. Can't wait to read your new book!
I agree with Tye that GOD's timing is amazing and many times mind blowing. receiving the knowledge from the period does give a new level of understanding.
Great comments guys! Stephen, you raise many good points. They were gathered in one place, but Dr. B argues thatsince it was required that Jews be in the temple. It is natural that the Galileans would have gathered together in one place. Secondly, the NT was certainly written in Greek. Most scholars hold that Hebraic styles and idioms exist in the Greek text because the authors relied on written Hebrew sources. Just as the phrase "I have hunger" is written in English but clearly Spanish is origin. Hope that makes sense. Trying to type it all from an iPhone.
Reading the blog, it does draw into questions the assumed place of the Holy Spirit's decent on Pentecost. Just some thoughts… In Kenneth Wuest's translation of Luke 1 & 2 it states "they were all together in the same place." (Lk 2:1) And the only previous indicator of location in reference to this statement is that "they went up to the upper room where they had taken up their residence for the ensuing time,"(Lk 2:13). And in reference to the “Hebraic-styled narrative break,” I thought the New Testament, at least the original manuscripts that are known of, were written in the older Greek language. Just wondering, and yes I am a nerd… Heh! :0) And finally, could the location of this event be outside of the temple being that all the disciples were Jewish and the place that they would “be” must specifically be the part of the temple that was exclusively for the Jews? If they were in the designated place for Jews, is it possible that the gentiles could hear their own language from the place that was designated for the non-Jews? Just questions as I read the blog. In Jerusalem at the site of the “upper room,” however, it is ironic to find that it sit on the second floor directly above the entrance to tomb of King David. That really blew me away! Wuest, K. S. (1997). The New Testament : An expanded translation (Ac 1:12–14). Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans.
that is very interesting. i have never understood it in that way. thank you for helping understand it.
Wow that was a real eye opener! I has always thought of them being in the upper room for the Pentecost experience. What a differece it made in my understanding of this passage when you dig in to the New Testament background. It just amazes me how God planned to have all of these people from all over world in one place, and then they were able to hear in their language "people" praising God!! This blog gave me a deeper understanding of the WHY of pentecost. 3000 people were born into the Kingdom of God all at once and filled over flowing with His Holy Spirit. They were able with the power of the Holy Spirit to spread the Gospel quickly in the world. What an awesome GOD we serve.
This clearly shows how easy it is to read a passage and just assume things and develop an erroneous mental picture. I never even really thought to wonder where the "upper room" was, not to mention I pictured a "room" crowded w/men; never fathomed tens of thousands of Jews being present! Shedding this much light on the story just radiates God's omnipotence, omnscience, and loving nature! I think I need to throw away my teaspoon and go get a bigger shovel!
I have never heard it explained that way. I always love hearing how God will coordinate certain times and details in the bible, and in people's lives. It gives me peace also.
I find that it is awesome to realize that when God poured out his spirit at Pentecost, as you states he chose the best time and place that would have the most impact on as many people as he could. It gives me peace in my own life knowing these details that God is truly in control especially when it comes to his people, his will, etc. Again knowing what the culture/historical background of the time as it relates to the scripture really does give an increased level of understanding.